The Editorially Independent Voice of The University of Akron

The Buchtelite

The Editorially Independent Voice of The University of Akron

The Buchtelite

The Editorially Independent Voice of The University of Akron

The Buchtelite

Graphic courtesy of Liv Ream; movie flyer from IMDB
In defense of Skinamarink
By Liv Ream, Arts and Entertainment Editor • October 1, 2023
Alternative Spring Break 2023 volunteers in Washington, D.C. Courtesy of Natalie Mowad.
Applications open for Akron’s 2024 Alternative Spring Break
By Taylor Lorence, Correspondent • October 1, 2023
The Northern Cheyenne tribe and community walking the ancient Portage Path from Portage Path CLC to the John Brown Home during a previous years First Peoples Day event. Photo courtesy of Portage Path Collaborative.
UA Holds events in celebration of North American First People’s Day   
By Shananne Lewis, Online Editor • September 28, 2023
White swan on water during daytime photo - Free Uk Image on Unsplash
The Swan's Rapture: a poem
By Emily Price, editor in chief • September 27, 2023
Desperately Seeking an Amazon Fighter, sculpture by Kimberly Chapman
"Easy Prey" art exhibit on display at Myers School of Art
By Taylor Lorence, Reporter, Secretary • September 21, 2023
“On the left, there’s me at work! I received the New Student Orientation “Gold Standard” award alongside 
and at the same time as my friend Gillian.”
Courtesy of Connor VanMaele
Fall 2023 Print Edition: Going the Distance
By Connor VanMaele, Correspondent • September 19, 2023
L to R: Steve Horner, Heather Barhorst, Haley Kuczynski, Shawna Blankenship, Brynley Harris, Jessie Redwine at the Pop-Up Pantry. Image Courtesy of ZipAssist.
ZipAssist Holds Community Resource Fair Tuesday, September 19 from 11 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. in the SU 2nd Floor
By Shananne Lewis, Correspondent • September 18, 2023
Film critic Liv Ream and friend pose for photo (Image via Liv Ream)
My Barbie experience
By Liv Ream, Film Critic • September 17, 2023

The individual mandate

Written by: Matthew Balsinger

A significant event is currently underway in our nation’s Supreme Court.

The highest court in the land is being asked to render a verdict on one of President Barack Obama’s first official achievements, the Affordable Health Care Act.

Of course, like with anything that Obama has done during his presidency, conservative, Tea Party “experts” emerge into our national debate crying about how the health care bill is unconstitutional.

The issue of constitutionality is currently exactly where it should be, before the Supreme Court, but I believe it is necessary to address some of the ridiculous claims made by many on the right side of the aisle. This issue is important because it affects every single one of us in the sense of how our government will interact with its people.

The first problem with many conservative arguments is that they result to emotional appeal.  They throw around words such as “communism” and “socialism” to force people to have an emotional response.  They don’t bother to explain what is wrong with socialism and communism in this context.  I would like to remind the people who make this argument that public libraries, police and fire departments, public transportation, public parks and roads are all socialist-like structures.

The second and most contentious part of this issue is individual mandate, which would require every American to have health care insurance.  Most conservatives will whine and throw temper tantrums about how socialist, communist and pure evil an individual mandate is, such as anti-affordable heath care act advocates such as Ann Coulter, Rush Limbaugh, Bernie Goldberg, Rick Santorum and half a thousand others, who have made claims that individual mandates go against the principles for which this country was founded on.  Perhaps we should take a look at history?

In 1797, President George Washington championed a bipartisan bill called the Standing Militia Act of 1797.  The entire purpose of this bill was to individually mandate that men between the ages of 18 and 25 were required to purchase and own a firearm.  That’s right; the socialist president George Washington undermined the principles that this nation was founded on to individually mandate that men of a certain age must purchase a specific item.  Or at least that’s what we would have to conclude if we listened to Republican armchair constitutional experts.

Though the Standing Militia Act of 1797 was never enforced, it sets the precedent that the federal government can mandate specific commendations to the citizens for the good of the country.  A standing militia would have been necessary to supporting the common defense and defending the common welfare, just as affordable health care supports the common welfare by shifting the financial burden of health care to everyone instead of just those who have insurance.

Under our current system, we do not turn individuals who may be sick away from health care.  However, the price to cover those who are not insured is passed onto those who do have insurance, as well as us the tax payers.  This is where it becomes necessary and proper for Congress to pass a law to regulate.

If you really think about it, some of the most successful government policies have been individual mandates.  Social Security is an individual mandate, but by paying into it automatically, you are guaranteed those services whenever you need them.

What makes health care any different?  Seriously, think about it, because we must decide what type of society that we want.  If you want a society that doesn’t care about its people and lets them die in the streets, we don’t need Social Security and individually mandated health insurance.  But if we want a society that does care about people and doesn’t want people dying in the streets, then it becomes necessary and proper for us to find a logical way to provide for those services.



Leave a Comment
More to Discover

Comments (0)

All comments that are well-informed, civil and relevant to the story are welcome. To leave a comment, please provide your name and email address. The Editorial Board reserves to right to remove any comment that is submitted under false pretenses or includes personal attacks, libel, hate speech, profanity, spam or inaccurate/misleading information. All comments are screened and are generally approved unless they are found to be found in violation of these standards. Readers who notice comments that appear to violate these standards are encouraged to contact the Online Editor at [email protected].
All The Buchtelite Picks Reader Picks Sort: Newest

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *